I’m a big believer in the concept that you can’t rewrite history, so I have to shrug my shoulders a bit as Bleacher Report’s Lyle Richardson discusses “5 NHL Trade Fails That Will Keep Haunting Teams During the 2025-26 Season“:
Detroit Red Wings Trade Jake Walman to the San Jose Sharks
On June 25, 2024, the Detroit Red Wings traded Jake Walman and a 2024 second-round pick to the San Jose Sharks for future considerations. The move raised eyebrows as the Wings appeared to give away a good defenseman who’d played well enough to earn a three-year contract extension the year before.
After the trade, The Athletic’s Max Bultman reported the move appeared to have been made to free up salary-cap space and to clear some space on a crowded blue line. Rumors later emerged claiming Walman had a rocky relationship with the coaching staff, frowning on his “extracurricular activities” during stoppages of play.
Walman, 29, had a good season with the last-place Sharks, earning a team-leading 23:11 of ice time per game and tallying a career-high 32 points in 50 games. On March 6, the rebuilding club flipped him to the Edmonton Oilers, where he had eight points in 15 regular-season games while logging 21:26 of ice time.
Considering how well Walman played with two different teams last season, the fact the Red Wings gave him away (and included a 2024 second-round pick in the deal) was not one of general manager Steve Yzerman’s finest moves. Their ongoing need for another top-four defenseman makes it even worse.
Continued; for better or worse, you can’t re-litigate the past.
Yes, having Walman would help the Wings’ blueline, and no, in retrospect, it was a very strange move, but whether the Red Wings were looking to make a bigger move that didn’t happen, or whether Walman somehow alienated the team’s coaches and management…
It happened. And the Detroit Red Wings’ coaches and management and players have to deal with it. It was weird for sure, but it’s done and over with, and to quote Royal Blood, “All we have is now.”
Now, the Red Wings need to add a top-four defenseman via trade sometime between now and the 2026 trade deadline, and in the interim, they’re going to have to make due with the blueline that they’ve got presently.