The Athletic’s Sean Gentille, Shayna Goldman and Dom Luszczyszyn have compiled a massive list of the NHL’s best players in a tiered fashion, per a 20-person panel.
Red Wings captain Dylan Larkin is listed as an All-Star, but a tenuous one in the “3B” category…
Dylan Larkin
Why he’s here
Larkin, at least in the eyes of our panel, has found his level. Depending on who you ask, he’s either a middle-of-the-pack first-line center or an elite 2C, but nobody had an issue with his placement in Tier 3B.
His performance at the 4 Nations Face-Off earned him praise, as did a big season from linemate Lucas Raymond. That helped raise Larkin from Tier 3C after two years in neutral. We also felt it appropriate to leave Tier 3C center-free, reflecting a drop-off after players such as Larkin — a decision one exec called “bang on.”
Detroit’s playoff drought with Larkin as their top forward prevents him from rising further. He could counter-balance that with more production, but he has one season in his last six with more than 70 points. Still, there’s a sense that miscast or not, he’d be a winning player in the right environment, and we wanted his placement to reflect that.
And Moritz Seider occupies the same tier, just below Larkin…
Continue reading Larkin, Seider, Raymond, DeBrincat and Edvinsson are ranked in The Athletic’s ‘Player Tiers’