Sportsnet’s Ryan Dixon posted a list of the top 25 players of the 2000’s (thus far), and he includes two career-long Red Wings on his list:
7. Pavel Datsyuk: Listen, there’s only one guy on this list whose name became an adjective this century and that is the sublime Detroit Red Wings centre who could steal the puck from an opponent in the Wings zone, head up ice, then juke around a defender with a “Datsykian” maneuver to bring everybody in Joe Louis Arena out of their seats. If we could quantify the amount of times an NHLer made other guys from the world’s best league just shake their heads, Datsyuk and Connor McDavid are probably the co-winners. Datsyuk won the Selke Trophy three straight years, from 2008 through 2010, then finished third in voting for each of the next three years. He also collected four consecutive Lady Byngs from 2006 to 2009. In four seasons from 2005-06 to 2008-09, Datsyuk recorded more points (368) than everybody except Sidney Crosby (397), Alex Ovechkin (420) and Joe Thornton (421). Basically, that means he was, for an extended period, simultaneously the best defensive forward in hockey and one of the absolute best offensive players. He was a rookie on the loaded Wings team that claimed the 2002 Cup and driving force on the one that won again in 2008 and lost the 2009 final to Pittsburgh.
…
4. Nick Lidstrom: Like Brodeur, Lidstrom did not win any individual hardware in the 1990s. Then he made it rain in the 2000s. The gifted defenceman won six Norris Trophies in a seven-year period, beginning in 2001. He then claimed a seventh at age 40 in 2011 after his second-last NHL campaign. Only Bobby Orr’s eight Norris wins exceed Lidstrom’s career total. In 2002, Lidstrom became the first European to win the Conn Smythe. Six years later, after Detroit’s second championship this century, in 2008, he became the first European captain on a Cup-winning club. From 1999-2000 through his final year, 2011-12, no defenceman put up more points than Lidstrom’s 719 in the regular season and 106 in the playoffs. Only his countryman, Victor Hedman, has more playoff points from the blueline this century (117).
Continued; I’ve never seen a more-skilled player than Datsyuk, and I’ve never seen a better defenseman than Nicklas Lidstrom.