The Athletic’s Shayna Goldman posted a “Concern-O-Meter” which discusses several topics this morning, and she offers due concern regarding the Red Wings’ terrible penalty-kill (and shaky defensive play overall). Here’s part of her set of comments about the Wings’ “D” and PK unit:
The Red Wings’ defense and penalty kill
Concern-o-meter: 9/10
After the Red Wings traded Jake Walman, it seemed like another shoe would drop. There had to be a splash waiting in the wings to solidify this roster. Instead, the team made a few low-key signings like Tyler Motte, Erik Gustafsson, Vladimir Tarasenko and Cam Talbot. But none of them moved the needle. Detroit isn’t much better defensively, and none of these players bring enough offense to offset that.
And now the team is dealing with the consequences.
Detroit’s five-on-five defense has completely tanked over the last stretch of play despite matchups against the Ducks, Penguins, Sharks, Islanders and Bruins, who have all struggled. And the team isn’t generating nearly enough offensively to make up for it.
But the most glaring flaw of this team is its short-handed play. And it isn’t anything new. Detroit allowed one of the highest rates of shots and expected goals against on the penalty kill last season, its goaltenders just made more timely saves to keep the team afloat.
This year, the Red Wings are even worse while short-handed. They’re bleeding shots and quality chances, conceding 10.8 expected goals against per 60. Only the Ducks give up more on the penalty kill. But no one allows a higher rate of goals against. Detroit’s 13.4 goals against per 60 is the worst mark of the analytics era right now.
Continued (paywall); I’m not going to deny that the Red Wings’ penalty-kill has been awful, and I’m of the mind that Detroit desperately needs to add a shut-down defenseman to help Moritz Seider and Simon Edvinsson out via trade.
I also know that one player isn’t going to get the entire job done, and that the Red Wings need both a better commitment from each and every one of their skaters to stop parting like the Red Sea when they face opponents’ forechecking or “speed games”…
And, as Goodman says, there are legitimate concerns about the way that Bob Boughner’s coaching is partially at fault here. I hate to bag on coaches, but Wings’ penalty-killing is just so damn awful that it has to be mentioned that Boughner’s in charge of that PK unit.
Things can still improve here, especially if the players buy into playing better defense, and the coaching staff incorporates some tweaks into their defensive and penalty-killing systems of play. But, “It ain’t good enough” right now, and for the Red Wings to even marginally succeed this season, they’ve absolutely got to rectify these two problem areas.