The Detroit News’s John Niyo posted a meaty Monday night column, discussing his top 20 Detroit sports trades of the past 30 years, across all Detroit’s four major sports franchises.
The Red Wings’ best trades–and Niyo lists 7 of them–have involved both taking advantage of other teams’ disgruntled players, and they’ve involved some calculus as to which players would end up providing the most value for their investment over the long haul:
3. Oct. 9, 1996: Red Wings trade Paul Coffey, Keith Primeau and 1997 first-round pick to Hartford for Brendan Shanahan and Brian Glynn
Shanahan wanted out of a hopeless situation in Hartford, and Primeau wasn’t happy with his role in Detroit. But the big winner in this trade was Scotty Bowman, who got the power forward he needed to help the Red Wings end their championship drought. Shanahan was a huge part of the Wings’ three Stanley Cups (1997-98, 2002), while Primeau had a solid career that ended a decade later due to post-concussion syndrome. Coffey, whose attempts to derail the trade enraged Bowman, ended up getting dealt again to Philadelphia, where the offensive-minded defenseman was on the losing end of the ’97 Cup finals. That first-round pick was Nikos Tselios, who played in just two NHL games.
In the case of Shanahan, the Red Wings were able to take advantage of another team’s disgruntled performer in landing the best player in the trade. While the Whalers/Hurricanes got a hell of a second-half career out of Keith Primeau, Coffey flamed out in Hartford and bounced around, finishing his playing days in Chicago.
5. July 1, 2001: Red Wings trade Vyacheslav Kozlov and 2002 first-round pick to Buffalo for Dominik Hasek
Adding the “Dominator” was a stunner, no doubt. Hasek was the top goalie in the world and had just won his sixth Vezina Trophy as the NHL’s best netminder. But with the Sabres in the midst of a roster teardown, Red Wings GM Ken Holland pounced on the opportunity to add another Hall of Famer to a stacked roster that was a few years removed from back-to-back Cup wins. Hasek replaced Chris Osgood in net and backstopped another title run, posting a 1.86 goals-against average with six shutouts in the playoffs. He briefly retired after that, then returned twice more to the Wings, winning another Cup in Detroit as Osgood’s backup in the 2008 playoffs. Kozlov, who’d been part of the Russian Five in Detroit, only spent one year in Buffalo before finishing his NHL career in Atlanta.
Again, Dom wanted “out” of Buffalo, and he essentially picked his own destination, so the Red Wings were able to offload the playoff-savvy Kozlov to Buffalo as a return. Kozlov actually had a fairly good tenure with the Thrashers, but they struggled to get over the playoff hump.
Continue reading Niyo discusses seven pivotal Red Wings trades made over the past three decades